Data day

MODULE 04 / 04

The reaction

Why the same surprise can push stocks up or down, which markets move first, how a US release travels around the world, and a routine for data day.

LESSON 1 / 4 · 7 MIN

The regime decides the sign

Understand why good news can be bad for stocks, and how to tell which regime you are in.

A strong jobs report is good news for the economy. For the stock market, it depends on what the market fears most at that moment. That fear is the regime, and it decides whether the same surprise pushes stocks up or down.

Strong dataWeak dataFear ofinflationFear forgrowthStocks downStocks upStocks upStocks downThe regime: what the market fears most right now
In fear of inflation, strong data pulls stocks down; in fear for growth, it pushes them up. The surprise is the same; the regime decides the sign.
RegimeStrong data means…Stocks
Inflation fearThe Fed will keep rates high or raise themDown ('good news is bad news')
Growth fearThe recession is further awayUp ('good news is good news')
GoldilocksModerate data is best; extremes in either direction worryDepends on the size

2022: inflation fear

On 13 September 2022, August CPI came in hotter than expected and the S&P 500 fell more than 4%, its worst day in over two years. On 10 November 2022, October CPI came in cooler than expected and the S&P 500 rose more than 5%. In both cases, the only thing that mattered was what the data meant for the Fed.

Key idea
To know the regime, do not ask the news. Look at the last few big surprises and how stocks reacted. If strong data made stocks fall, you are in inflation fear. The regime changes, but slowly — usually over months.
Practice
For the next three big releases, write down the surprise (sign and size) and the S&P 500's move that day. Then answer: which regime is the market in?
On the site · /calendar
On /calendar, go back over the last high-impact US releases and write down each surprise: it is the first column of your regime table.
Open it on the site →
Check yourself

Payrolls come in far above forecast and the S&P 500 falls 1.5%. Which regime does that suggest?