A portfolio without scares

MODULE 04 / 04

Measuring and correcting

Comparing yourself with the right benchmark, the habit of selling winners and holding losers, writing your rules down and a monthly review in fifteen minutes.

LESSON 1 / 4 · 6 MIN

Are you beating the benchmark?

Compare your portfolio's return with what a simple index fund would have done in the same period.

Earning 8% in a year sounds good. If the S&P 500 rose 20% that year, you earned 12 points less than you would have with a single, cheap fund and no work. Your return only means something next to a benchmark.

  • ▸If your portfolio is mostly US stocks, the natural benchmark is the S&P 500.
  • ▸If it is mostly technology, compare it with the Nasdaq 100 as well.
  • ▸If it mixes stocks and bonds, compare it with a mix in the same proportions.
Key idea
Beating the index is hard even for professionals: according to S&P's SPIVA reports, around nine out of ten US large-cap active funds have trailed the S&P 500 over 15-year periods. If you do not beat it for several years, that is information, not bad luck.
Tip
Compare over the same dates. A portfolio started in March is measured against the index from March, not from January.
On the site · /ytd-roi
Open /ytd-roi, choose 'Indexes' and look at where the S&P 500 is this year (each year starts at 1.0). That is the number your portfolio has to beat.
Open it on the site →
Check yourself

Your portfolio of US stocks earned 8% this year and the S&P 500 earned 20%. What does that tell you?